Investing Beyond The Noise

Beyond market cycles – Building conviction using fundamentals & valuation discipline

Financial markets are shaped by changing narratives, economic cycles and investor sentiment. Strong market performance often creates excessive optimism, while corrections test investors’ confidence. Successful investing requires more than identifying businesses with attractive growth prospects. It requires understanding earnings quality, paying the right price and maintaining discipline through market cycles

India’s equity market provides an interesting example of why earnings quality; valuation discipline; and investor behaviour are so important for long term wealth creation.

India’s earnings story – consistency matters

The story for India’s investment case is not necessarily about having the highest earnings growth of emerging markets. It’s about consistency and quality of that earnings growth.

Since 2010, Indian companies have delivered an earnings per share (EPS) CAGR of approximately 9.1%, with only three years of declining earnings over the 16-year period. Further, around 28% of Indian companies have delivered an average return on equity (ROE) above 20% over ten years, second only to the United States.

The above highlights an important difference. Sustainable profitability & consistent earnings growth can be more valuable than short bursts of extreme growth.

Therefore, when we look at the recent moderation of earnings, we need to be careful. Moderation doesn’t necessarily mean structural deterioration. We need to differentiate between cyclical weakness vs a permanent change in the competitive position, profitability, or growth prospects of a company.

Valuations – the link between business performance & returns

Earnings growth is only one part of the equation. The valuation you enter at can have a significant impact on the returns you ultimately realize.

Historical data across five emerging markets shows that stocks trading at relatively lower P/E valuations delivered an average annualised return of 11.5% over the following three years. In comparison, stocks trading at the highest P/E valuations generated just 3.5%.

Looking at India since 2019, the relationship holds true. While the earnings growth CAGR was approx. 17.5%, the returns on the index were approx. 10.7%. Part of the reason is that we saw a contraction in valuations of approx. 13%. As a result, strong earnings growth did not translate into proportionate index returns, because investors were willing to pay a lower multiple for those earnings.

At current starting valuations, India’s long term trend EPS growth of approx. 9.1% could allow for approx. 9-10% annualised returns (in local currency) without any meaningful re-rating of valuations. (This is an illustrative example, not a forecast or guarantee).

The broader point is that even with a fundamentally strong business, you can still end up with disappointing returns if you purchase it at an excessive valuation.

Must Read: Why 2026 Could Be the Right Time to Invest in Large-Caps

Looking beyond recent performance

Recent performance of markets can be misleading with respect to future opportunities. For example, Taiwan & South Korea have seen exceptional growth in earnings. Partly driven by the semiconductor & AI investment cycle.

In these markets, earnings growth has become increasingly concentrated. SK Hynix, TSMC and Samsung account for nearly 70% of profit growth in their respective markets. South Korea’s post-COVID EPS CAGR of approximately 26% compares with just 3.1% over 2010–2025. Meanwhile, Taiwan’s valuation has reached the 96th–98th percentile of its historical range.

These examples highlight the risk of extrapolating peak cycle earnings into the future. You need to assess if the growth is structural & sustainable or is it largely a function of a favourable business cycle.

Building conviction through market cycles

Investment conviction is often tested during market corrections. Rather than bull markets. Investors tend to get more and more confident during bull markets. Chasing investments that have performed well. During corrections, the same investors may begin to question their decisions and lose confidence.

You don’t want conviction to be driven by past performance or market popularity. Conviction should come from understanding the business, the fundamentals, the valuation and the investment process of the portfolio.

This is especially true for value oriented/contrarian investing. When you take a different view than the market, you need to do the research and be patient. Short term price declines don’t necessarily invalidate your investment thesis. If the underlying fundamentals are intact.

But, you don’t want conviction to become stubbornness. When business fundamentals change, or your original investment thesis changes. You need to re-assess decisions. It’s important to understand the investment philosophy. Trust the process. Allow for the appropriate time horizon to sustain your conviction. Also, be careful of taking action on unaccountable advice or investing in things just because they are popular.

Portfolio construction – conviction to discipline

It’s not just about having great investment ideas. You need to evaluate each opportunity in the context of risk; valuation; expected returns; and its contribution to the overall portfolio.

A structured process involves identifying businesses with sustainable profitability. Assessing growth prospects. Assessing valuations. Determining appropriate portfolio allocations. Ranking opportunities and sizing positions based on their risk/return characteristics. To ensure conviction is reflected through disciplined portfolio construction.

You also need to monitor things on an ongoing basis. Periodically re-validate investment decisions as new information becomes available. Ensure you are objective (especially during difficult market conditions). Understand the rationale for changes to the portfolio.

The goal is not to respond to every market movement. But to differentiate short term volatility vs changes that actually impact the long term value of the business.

Bottom line

Markets will go through periods of optimism; uncertainty; corrections. You can’t control the market cycles. But you can control the quality of your decisions.

Long term wealth creation comes from finding businesses with sustainable fundamentals. Investing at sensible valuations. Constructing portfolios with an appropriate understanding of risk. Sustaining conviction through market cycles.

Be patient when you see opportunities being overlooked. But be objective enough to change course if facts change. To separate the performance chasers from the disciplined investors.

“Markets may reward momentum in the short term. But, lasting wealth is built through sound businesses; sensible valuations; and the discipline to stay focused on the long term.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top